TubShroom Ultra Revolutionary Bath Tub Drain Protector Hair — 4.7 Stars. But Is It Really That Good?
Introduction
I've been using the TubShroom Ultra bath tub drain protector for about six months now, and after that time I have a pretty clear picture of where it shines and where it falls short. When I first ordered it I was skeptical — the idea of a silicone "mushroom" that you push into the drain to catch hair sounded clever, but I'd tried several other strainers over the years that either clogged, smelled, or simply let the hair slip past. The TubShroom Ultra claims to collect hair on the outside of the stem so it never blocks the flow, and that appealed to me as someone who hates standing ankle-deep in slow-draining water after a shower.
In this review I'll walk through my hands-on experience: installation, day-to-day performance, cleaning, durability, and compatibility with different drain types. I'll also share concrete pros and cons, a comparison against other drain-catcher options I own, and a buying guide so you can decide whether it makes sense for your bathroom. I'm writing as a real user — what I found was a mix of genuinely useful design choices and a few annoyances I didn't expect.
Product review and analysis
What I received and first impressions
The TubShroom Ultra arrived in a small package and felt like a dense, flexible silicone piece in my hand. In my experience, the material felt sturdier and slightly thicker than the cheap silicone strainers I had before. It compresses to fit into the drain opening and stands upright like a small mushroom. Right away I appreciated the clean, simple form — no metal basket to rust, no tiny holes that clog instantly. I installed it within a minute the first time and ran a little test with the shower running to judge drainage speed and stability.
Installation and fit
Installation was straightforward. I pushed the TubShroom Ultra into the tub drain until the collars made contact with the tub surface. It sat snugly without needing tools. In my experience it fit my standard size tub drain very well and stayed put during showers. One thing I learned quickly: the Ultra's fit is best in drains with a defined throat — it doesn't work as well on very wide, flat drain openings or some pop-up style drains where the rubber plug mechanism sits flush. I tested it in two tubs in my home and it fit one perfectly and required some gentle repositioning in the other where the drain flange is shallow.
Performance: hair-catching and drainage
After several weeks I could say the TubShroom Ultra does exactly what it promises most of the time. The hair tends to wrap around the outside of the stem rather than getting stuck in a top grate, so the water keeps flowing while the hair accumulates. With long hair in the household, I found the Ultra needed emptying roughly every 3–5 showers; that frequency will obviously vary by how much shedding you and your household produce. What I appreciated was that even when it was holding a fair amount of hair, the shower water still drained quickly — much faster than my old metal cup-style strainer.
That said, it's not perfect. I noticed that very short hairs (the kind that come off after a haircut or from a pet) sometimes slipped past the stem and collected further down in the drain. Also, if you have a tub with heavy soap scum buildup or oily residue, the catch can get slick and some strands slide down when you remove the device. In my experience this was a minor inconvenience compared with the amount of hair it actually prevented from going into the plumbing.
Cleaning and maintenance
Cleaning the TubShroom Ultra is simple: I pull it up, pinch the base, and slide the hair off the stem into the trash. Because the hair collects outside the stem, it comes off in one solid clump most of the time — which is satisfying. Twice in six months I scrubbed it with a brush and dish soap because soap scum accumulated inside the grooves where the stem meets the cup, but this was quick and infrequent.
One thing that bothered me initially was a faint rubber smell during the first few uses. It faded after a week of wetting and rinsing. After a few months the silicone still looks like new with no discoloration, although if you don't rinse it occasionally it can develop a film from soap and conditioner residue. I started rinsing it once a week during my cleaning routine and that kept it fresh.
Shop the latest Tools & Home Improvement picks on Amazon.
Shop Amazon →Durability after months of use
At around the six-month mark the material still feels intact — no cracks, no tearing — and it hasn't lost its ability to compress and seal into the drain opening. Compared to plastic strainers I used previously, this feels like a long-lasting option. I did notice that the edges of the outer collar began to show tiny lint-like deposits where minerals from hard water built up. A quick scrub with a non-abrasive pad fixed that right away.
Compatibility and limitations
In my experience, the best fit is for standard tub drains without a complex pop-up or lift-and-turn mechanism. If your drain has a built-in pop-up that sits flush, the TubShroom Ultra may not sit deep enough to catch hair effectively or may interfere with the pop-up. It also doesn't work well in very shallow or overly wide drains where there's not enough throat for the stem to seat against. If you have a clawfoot tub or non-standard drain geometry, I'd recommend measuring the throat depth before buying.
Pros & Cons
- Pros:
- Captures large amounts of hair on the outside of the stem so water keeps draining.
- Easy to install — no tools required and fits most standard tub drains.
- Simple cleaning: hair usually comes off in one clump.
- Durable silicone stands up to months of use without cracking.
- No metal parts to rust and simple to rinse if you keep up with basic cleaning.
- Cons:
- Not compatible with every drain type (pop-up or very shallow drains can be a problem).
- Very short hairs and some small debris can still slip past into the drain.
- Initial rubber smell for the first few uses, though it fades with cleaning.
- Can accumulate soap residue and minerals if not rinsed periodically.
Comparison: TubShroom Ultra vs other drain protectors I own
| Product | Catch Rate (my experience) | Ease of Installation | Cleaning | Compatibility Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| TubShroom Ultra | High — catches majority of long strands, needs emptying every few showers in my household | Very easy — push-fit into standard drains | Very easy — hair pulls off in one clump; occasional scrub | Best for standard tub drains; less ideal for pop-up and very shallow drains |
| Original TubShroom | Moderate to high — similar concept but less robust material | Easy — similar push-in installation | Easy — hair removal similar, but material felt thinner | Works for most tub drains but felt less durable over months |
| Metal basket strainer | Moderate — catches hair but often clogs the grate | Simple — drops in place | Difficult — hair wraps inside holes and requires brushing | Universal fit, but rust and clogging are common issues |
| Flat silicone snap-on cover | Low — often lets hair slip beneath it | Easy — sits on the top surface | Moderate — needs wiping and rinsing | Works for some drains but causes slow drainage if clogged |
Buying guide: what to look for when choosing a tub drain hair catcher
If you're considering the TubShroom Ultra or other drain protectors, here are the practical things I looked for and why they mattered in daily use.
1. Material and durability
I preferred soft, flexible silicone over thin plastic or metal because it resists cracking and rusting. After months of use,…2. Catching method
Some strainers work by collecting hair on top (which tends to block water), others like the TubShroom collect hair around a central stem so water drains freely. Think about whether you want the catcher to prioritize uninterrupted drainage or maximal capture. I found the latter approach more user-friendly for showers where quick drainage matters.
3. Ease of cleaning
How you remove hair matters. Devices that let you pull the hair off in one clump are more hygienic and less messy. If you dread sticking your hand under the drain grate to fish out fussy tangles, pick a model designed for grab-and-pull removal.
4. Fit and compatibility
Measure your drain's throat depth and check whether the device fits pop-up mechanisms. If possible, look for models that explicitly state compatibility with your type of drain. In my home, acknowledging that not all drains are standard saved me from a return.
5. Odor and mold resistance
Some materials can trap moisture and develop odors. I found rinsing once a week prevented any mildew. If you live in a humid climate, pick silicone options that are easy to remove and quick to dry.
Looking for the best Tools & Home Improvement deals on Amazon?
Shop Amazon →6. Maintenance schedule
Be realistic about how often you'll empty the catcher. In my experience, expect to empty it every few showers in a household with longer hair, and less often in a single-person household with short hair. Buy a device that is easy to handle with wet hands.
7. Aesthetics and finish
While function is primary, look at available colors and finishes if the drain is visible. I kept mine in a neutral color that blends with the tub, but some people appreciate a bright accent color to make the catcher easier to find.
Real-world tips from months of use
After using the TubShroom Ultra daily, a few practical tips emerged:
- Rinse the device weekly to prevent soap film buildup — a quick brush under warm water works wonders.
- If short hairs slip past, try a separate small mesh strainer installed deeper in the pipe for added protection.
- When removing hair, do it over a paper towel or trash can to avoid clumps falling into the tub.
- If your drain has a pop-up mechanism, test the depth by measuring or temporarily sliding something similar in size into the throat — the Ultra needs some throat depth to seat properly.
Conclusion
In my experience, the TubShroom Ultra is a solid step up from traditional cup strainers and thin silicone covers. After six months of regular use it has reliably caught the bulk of long hair that used to climb into my drain, reduced slow-drain incidents, and required only straightforward maintenance. The design that collects hair around the outside of a stem is intelligently executed — it keeps water flowing while you shower and simplifies cleanup.
That said, it's not a magic bullet. Very short hairs can still make it past the stem, and it's not compatible with every drain type out of the box. I was also slightly annoyed by a short-lived rubber smell during the first week, though it dissipated. If your home has standard tub drains and you want a low-hassle, durable solution that minimizes clogs and keeps water draining well, the TubShroom Ultra is worth considering. If you have a pop-up drain or shallow throat, measure first or consider a different style of strainer.
Ultimately, after months of daily use I can honestly say it improved my bathroom routine: I empty it quickly, I rarely have to plunge, and the plumbing feels less stressed. That practical improvement — fewer clogs and less time spent dealing with them — is why I've kept the TubShroom Ultra in my tub.